PubMed, created by the US National Library of Medicine in DATE, holds bibliographic records and abstracts for essentially all journal articles published in the biomedical sciences. It currently records almost a million new entries each year!
PubMed Central (PMC), created as an extension of PubMed, is designed to hold full text articles from among the PubMed entries. At present, PMC holds entries for ~9.3% of the papers indexed in PubMed published between 1980 and 2010, 1,428,675 out of a total of 15,319,102. Many of these PMC articles (192,452 for the years 1980 to 2010, ~13.5% of the PMC holdings) are truly Open Access articles, that users can download and repurpose as they will. However, the majority are articles from subscription access journals deposited in PMC under licence agreements with funding agencies that, while providing read access to the full text, prevent readers from downloading the articles and from making derivative works.
The Open Citations Project has to date worked exclusively with the Open Access subset (OASS) of PMC. As of 24 January 2011, there were 204,637 OASS articles, including a few published before 1980. In almost all of these OASS articles, the reference lists were nicely marked up in NLM-DTD XML, making the task of identifying individual references straightforward. In a few cases, the articles were present as scanned page images, lacking any internal markup – those we were unable to process.
From the XML reference lists of these papers, we were able to identify and extract 6,325,178 individual references, which, together with the bibliographic information we had on the OASS articles themselves gave us 6,529,815 independent bibliographic records of both citing and cited entities. As explained in the next blog post, these records showed varying degrees of completeness and accuracy.
Using the Entrez API, we were able to use PubMed IDs, where these were available in the references, to extract a further 2,304,143 bibliographic records from PubMed, which, in the ideal world, would each exactly duplicate the information we had previously obtained from the OASS bibliographic reference containing that PubMed ID. As we shall describe, these additional PubMed records proved exceptionally useful in correcting imperfect OASS references.
Since the OASS articles cite papers outside the OASS, as well as a few within it, the majority of the bibliographic information we thus acquired related to papers represented within PubMed but not within PubMed Central. And because many OASS papers independently contained references to the most highly cited biomedical papers, many of our records were to the same bibliographic entities.
An important part of our data processing was thus to coalesce independent references from different OASS articles to the same multiply cited papers into a set of unique bibliographic records, each for one paper. Once this had been achieved, we were left with 3,578,598 unique bibliographic records, 204,637 describing the OASS articles themselves, and 3,373,961 describing articles outside the OASS, mostly from subscription-access journals.
The following table and figure tabulates and illustrates the number of papers in each category between 1980 and 2010 inclusive. The most striking thing about these data are that they show how, between these years, the relatively small number of articles in the Open Access subset of PMC (approx. 200,000 articles) referenced >20% of all PubMed Central papers published between 1950 and 2010 (approx. 15.3 million papers), and in doing so reference all the most important highly cited papers in every field of biomedical endeavour. This inclusive coverage means that citation graphs created from the Open Citations dataset will capture all the important aspects of any field.
Table 1
Year |
Number of papers |
|||
Pubmed |
PMC |
OASS |
Cited by OASS |
|
1950-1979 |
5,128,602 |
427,877 |
8352 |
146027 |
1980 |
278,069 |
23,218 |
631 |
15708 |
1981 |
278,069 |
23,685 |
543 |
16627 |
1982 |
292,219 |
25,215 |
740 |
18389 |
1983 |
305,725 |
25,688 |
738 |
21263 |
1984 |
314,737 |
26,316 |
543 |
23249 |
1985 |
331,706 |
25,916 |
637 |
25780 |
1986 |
345,501 |
26,721 |
590 |
28761 |
1987 |
363,754 |
27,834 |
555 |
32222 |
1988 |
381,976 |
28,802 |
442 |
36320 |
1989 |
398,620 |
29,855 |
616 |
42005 |
1990 |
398,620 |
30,143 |
704 |
48422 |
1991 |
407,465 |
31,337 |
733 |
53655 |
1992 |
412,457 |
32,325 |
719 |
61091 |
1993 |
420,935 |
33,203 |
1055 |
70272 |
1994 |
431,160 |
33,456 |
1279 |
80206 |
1995 |
441,967 |
34,276 |
1148 |
91814 |
1996 |
452,218 |
34,755 |
1155 |
101853 |
1997 |
451,533 |
34,800 |
1314 |
114967 |
1998 |
469,466 |
36,179 |
1341 |
131510 |
1999 |
469,466 |
37,534 |
1420 |
146623 |
2000 |
528,243 |
39,047 |
1608 |
170330 |
2001 |
542,854 |
40,235 |
2546 |
179203 |
2002 |
560,006 |
43,265 |
3199 |
195879 |
2003 |
590,317 |
46,442 |
4015 |
211423 |
2004 |
634,432 |
51,416 |
6005 |
229423 |
2005 |
694,687 |
60,411 |
10333 |
236678 |
2006 |
740,007 |
72,295 |
14264 |
238387 |
2007 |
777,311 |
87,744 |
20070 |
222085 |
2008 |
824,612 |
120,004 |
31416 |
190071 |
2009 |
862,372 |
146,413 |
41848 |
124894 |
2010 |
918,598 |
120,145 |
40245 |
27877 |
Total |
15,319,102 |
1,428,675 |
192,452 |
3,186,987 |
% of PubMed |
9.33% |
20.80% |
||
% of PMC |
13.47% |
Figure 1
Figure 2
The OASS source data give the types of cited entity, aggregated after coalescing, shown in the Figure 3.
Figure 3
OpenEdition suggests that you cite this post as follows:
davidshotton (July 1, 2011). Input data for Open Citations – the PMC Open Access Subset. OpenCitations blog. Retrieved December 8, 2024 from https://doi.org/10.58079/sjbw
0 thoughts on “Input data for Open Citations – the PMC Open Access Subset”